So there are many things that people say about taking tests. Some think tests are evil, some say you can't have school with out them. And I am sure there are many, MANY more view points.
But really when you look at assessments - what is it that you are trying to measure? That can usually help determine what kind of test you are writing and what kind of test the student should be taking.
Traditionally - the idea of a test in school was to give the student a ranking or grade of where they stood on a certain set of data. It was pretty straight forward - this is what you are suppose to learn, then you test to see if they know it. Yes there are some faults with that line of thinking - like can the students actually USE the data - or is it just memorized, but that is another discussion for another time.
Now, tests are being used to evaluate teaching programs and even teachers themselves - but often times the test look exactly the same as the old style of tests that is just about a certain set of data. The obvious problem with this type of evaluation is the fact that you are using the students to do the testing - what if the student has a learning disability or just had a bad day. Or even worse the student KNOWS that the test is a reflection on the teacher/school and bombs it on purpose because they don't like the teacher or school.
And think about some of the tests . . . let's say a timed math test in 1st grade. You are NOT actually testing the students understanding of math concepts, you are testing how QUICKLY they can apply them. Or - after seeing the homework and rote memorization of addition of single digit number - you are seeing how quickly they can regurgitate simple addition equations. How is that a good test of their skill - and even further how is that an appropriate evaluation of the teacher? The teacher can get students to memorize something . . . is that teaching?
So the big question is - how to do test for "learning" without punishing the student?
Showing posts with label Assessment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Assessment. Show all posts
Friday, May 17, 2013
Thursday, March 14, 2013
#6 Isolation doesn't really work
Okay - I was going to say Isolation doesn't really exist - but that isn't right - but really when talking about topics to learn . . . does teaching something in isolation really work? It isn't ever used that way. As an adult I don't think that I have ever had a math problem that doesn't have some sort of "story" with it . . . now I am not a mathematician or even a scientists that relies on mathematical equations, but I am a working adult and I do use math.
For a while I was an actor, and you might think "oh well that person uses one skill" - but no, I had to memorize lines, move around a stage, follow direction, analyze my character and a few (hundred) other things - so why would I be taught all of those things separately.
I can see maybe saying that the foundations of each topic might need special, individualized attention - before you can really get into "figuring" in math you do need the basics of addition and subtraction. But really, most kids can work this into their regular learning, they really do figure out addition and subtraction as concepts. (And really we test on that idea of can you do so many math problems in a minute - really this is a test that we do to our kids?!?!?!)
As adult - working adult - do we ever sit down and just do math problems?
Now, maybe I am being a little harsh on math, but let's think about history - don't worry - I am not going to say that we should just ignore history - I do actually think it is valuable to learn about! However, by stripping away all context and even the stories with it, and having to teach it independent of anything else - we make it SO BORING - and really, kinda useless. Other than historians, and people who want to go into that field - who really liked history classes in college??? But think - if we had a class that was called "problem solving" and the discussion would be about different methods of creating change. The class structure would then be to read a specific time in history, a big event, and then the class time would be spent discussing what could have been done differently to change the outcomes. MAN - think about it, not only would students be reading history, but they would also be identifying ways that they could make changes. . . what a great lesson that would be!!!
So - my big thought for today is - DON'T teach subjects in isolation - put them in context, teach with real world lessons, even to kids - but really, REALLY work towards putting it altogether for the people that are learning.
For a while I was an actor, and you might think "oh well that person uses one skill" - but no, I had to memorize lines, move around a stage, follow direction, analyze my character and a few (hundred) other things - so why would I be taught all of those things separately.
I can see maybe saying that the foundations of each topic might need special, individualized attention - before you can really get into "figuring" in math you do need the basics of addition and subtraction. But really, most kids can work this into their regular learning, they really do figure out addition and subtraction as concepts. (And really we test on that idea of can you do so many math problems in a minute - really this is a test that we do to our kids?!?!?!)
As adult - working adult - do we ever sit down and just do math problems?
Now, maybe I am being a little harsh on math, but let's think about history - don't worry - I am not going to say that we should just ignore history - I do actually think it is valuable to learn about! However, by stripping away all context and even the stories with it, and having to teach it independent of anything else - we make it SO BORING - and really, kinda useless. Other than historians, and people who want to go into that field - who really liked history classes in college??? But think - if we had a class that was called "problem solving" and the discussion would be about different methods of creating change. The class structure would then be to read a specific time in history, a big event, and then the class time would be spent discussing what could have been done differently to change the outcomes. MAN - think about it, not only would students be reading history, but they would also be identifying ways that they could make changes. . . what a great lesson that would be!!!
So - my big thought for today is - DON'T teach subjects in isolation - put them in context, teach with real world lessons, even to kids - but really, REALLY work towards putting it altogether for the people that are learning.
Labels:
Adult Ed,
Assessment,
Communication,
Early Ed,
Elementary Ed,
Secondary Ed
Friday, March 1, 2013
#1 Get Rid Of Standardized Tests
I know a lot of educators that like standardized test - and I know that I have used them from time to time. They are a "great way to see where everyone stands" and various other things. Even the idea of "what you assess is what gets better"
BUT
In so many educational systems the teaching slowly transforms into a class on how to pass the test. NOT about the knowledge or the application of the knowledge that should happen.
The focus of education - at all levels should be about learning and how to apply that. Basically it should be about thinking. How to think, how to come to an answer, how to figure it out - and unfortunately when we need to pass a standardized test, what we are "teaching" is how to memorize specific points of data.
Having moved from child/young adult education into working with adult and seeing how their formal education is sometimes a detriment to their workplace success - you can tell the students that are GREAT at passing tests, but in work they usually are not the most successful employees.
On the flip side, I have seen it time and time again where employees that are doing really well (and I have asked them to co-teach with me) they have said "but I am not good in school" or "I have failed so many tests - I wouldn't be a good teacher." But really what they are saying is "I didn't do well on standardized test, so got bad grades. However, I figured out how to think for myself and now really know how to ____(what ever the topic is that we are trying to cover)."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
